Kate McCann “How Do You Prove Innocence?”

Gerry McCann “It Was Like Dining In Your Backgarden”

Tavares de Almeida: When we asked UK for info on McCanns we got a single side of A4

Posted by Stevo on Jan 12th, 2010 and filed under Famous Articles. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

At the start of the libel trial in Lisbon today, Tavares de Almeida is cross-examined by the McCanns legal team.

Sr. Almeida pulls no punches and the McCanns’ lawyer is rebuked for making a false allegation against Sr. Almeida.

Here is a blow-by-blow account of the events in the courtroom courtesy of Sky’s Jon di Paolo:

Live From Court in Lisbon: Morning Session

8:40: [Jon di Paolo] Good morning, I’m outside the Palacio da Justica in Lisbon where the McCann libel trial will take place.
9:03: Camera crews and photographers are gathering outside the court.
9:05: The police have put barriers up outside the court entrance – they’re obviously expecting large crowds.
9:52: The McCanns have arrived at court. Word so far is that Goncalo Amaral is still yet to get here.
10:20: We’re in court awaiting the arrival of the judge and legal teams. The McCanns are sitting in the front row at the centre.
10:23: We’re sitting two rows behind the McCanns. The benches at the back of the courtroom are full of journalists from the UK and Portugal.
10:25: The legal teams have arrived. Goncalo Amaral is sitting on one of the benches at the side of the court, around 15ft away from the McCanns.
10:28: On the wall above the judge’s chair is a large 3D frieze depicting the judgement of Solomon – complete with baby being held up by swordsman.
10:36: A clerk carrying a large bundle of files has just come in, but we’re still waiting for the judge.
10:39: The judge has arrived – a young woman! Proceedings should now be able to get under way.
10:41: One of the policemen set to give evidence will do so by video link tomorrow, we are told.
10:46: Mr Amaral’s lawyer addresses the court, speaking very slowly and deliberately.
10:47: He is declaring the ‘principle of contradiction’ – the legal basis for Mr Amaral’s argument to be made.
10:47: Mr Amaral’s lawyer has said that the McCanns should take the stand in order to answer questions.
10:51: The McCanns’ lawyer replies that the couple are prepared to give evidence but only after Mr Amaral has done so.
10:52: The McCanns are having proceedings translated by interpreters seated either side of them.
11:00: The McCanns’ legal team is calling a new witness, Luis Frois, on a date to be scheduled on the 14th.
11:01: The mention of ‘a date to be scheduled on the 14th’ indicates proceedings are set to last longer than the three days set for them.
11:07: Mr Amaral’s lawyers want a CD containing police case files to be submitted as evidence because it would corroborate the claims in his book.
11:11: The McCanns’ lawyer is arguing against allowing the police CD to be submitted to the court.
11:20: The first witness is being called by videoconference.
11:23: It is the attorney who was in charge of the original inquiry into Madeleine’s disappearance, Jose Magalhaes e Menezes.
11:25: His testimony is marred by a high-pitched whine of feedback from the microphone – and the fact the screen can’t be seen by the public.
11:26: The McCanns can’t see the person giving evidence. Mr Amaral can, but doesn’t seem to be looking at him.
11:26: Mr Amaral’s lawyer is cross-examining the witness.
11:37: Mr Menezes is saying that English police sniffer dogs were brought in to help in the search for Madeleine.
11:38: He says that the decision to make the McCanns ‘arguidos’ – suspects – was taken by the police and then confirmed by the public attorney.
11:39: The decision to designate Kate and Gerry as ‘arguidos’ was taken after the sniffer dogs carried out their searches.
11:40: There were several possible charges that could have been brought against the McCanns: kidnapping and selling a child were among them.
11:48: The witness was asked what the probability was of Madeleine still being alive. He replied that he thought it was 50/50.
11:55: Mr Menezes said that a claim made by the McCanns on the first day after Madeleine’s disappearance was not true.
11:56: The witness said that Kate and Gerry’s report that they had been checking on their daughter every half an hour was inaccurate.
11:57: He claimed that although the parents had been checking on Madeleine, it was not as often as every 30 minutes.
12:01: Police intercepted text messages sent by the McCanns because they were suspicious of the parents’ role in Madeleine’s disappearance.
12:02: The text messages sent by Kate and Gerry were never admitted as evidence gathered as part of the investigation.
12:08: Mr Menezes said he has not read the book written by Mr Amaral that triggered this case, Maddie: The Truth of the Lie.
12:18: A report signed by Chief Inspector Tavares De Almeida said that Madeleine died in the flat in Praia da Luz, the witness adds.
12:19: Now it is the turn of the McCanns’ legal team to cross-question the witness.
12:24: The McCanns’ lawyer makes the point that ‘evidence’ usually sightings – has suggested Madeleine is still alive.
12:25: He says that the McCanns are not responsible for generating any of this ‘evidence’ that their daughter is not dead.
12:26: Another of the McCanns’ lawyers moves to quiz the witness – literally. She gets out of her seat and walks right up to the video screen.
12:33: She says that the McCanns were always totally prepared to come back to Portugal to take part in a reconstruction of the disappearance.
12:34: The McCanns’ lawyer asks the witness whether he understands the title of Mr Amaral’s book to imply some sort of dishonesty by the McCanns.
12:38: Who suggested the checking of the McCanns’ text messages, Mr Menezes is asked. The police, he replies.
12:39: The text messages were never considered as part of the investigation because the judge did not allow it, the court hears.
12:45: The senior lawyer for the McCanns has approached them on the front bench of the public gallery for a quick huddled conversation.
12:48: Tavares de Almeida, chief inspector of police at the time of Madeleine’s disappearance, has taken the stand to give evidence.
12:48: He was involved in the case from the beginning, but taken off it in September 2007.
12:51: Mr de Almeida tells the court that he is still working as member of the Portuguese police.
12:52: He tells the court that British police took an active part in the investigation.
12:53: He said the Portuguese detectives found the co-operation given by their British counterparts useful.
12:54: The British police told the Portuguese officers what the capabilities of the sniffer dogs being used in the investigation were.
12:56: One of the dogs used to search the apartment in Praia da Luz identified blood and another identified the smell of a human body.
12:58: The dogs detected the traces inside the dining room of the holiday flat and in the car the McCanns were using.
1:02: The animals also found a scent on a piece of cloth in a flat rented by the McCanns after they left the apartment where Madeleine vanished.
1:11: A report by the British police stated that one of the sniffer dogs was in a nervous, excitable state, and wanted to get into the room.
1:34: British police would have found it very difficult to charge the McCanns.
1:35: De Almeida: we were controlled by the British police.
1:36: De Almeida: British police kept information about the McCanns to themselves.
1:39: De Almeida: Forensic lab technicians from Birmingham came to Portugal so it is strange concerns were raised about contamination.
1:53: De Almeida: British authorities other than police hindered investigation by withholding information.
1:54: De Almeida: when we asked UK for info on McCanns we got a single side of a4.
2:05: The McCanns’ lawyer is getting quite worked up in her cross examination of de Almeida.
2:09: The McCanns’ lawyer is rebuked for saying de Almeida was accused of torturing suspects – he was never charged.
2:10: The court is adjourning for lunch. Back at 3pm.

Afternoon Session

3:28: We’re back in court. The McCanns are here but Mr Amaral is missing.
3:29: Mr Amaral has just walked in and we are under way.
3:33: Inspector Ricardo Paiva, of the Portuguese police, has taken the stand.
3:34: Inspector Paiva says he was the family liaison officer for the case but was taken off at the McCanns’ request.
3:45: Paiva is asked whether he ever got the impression from the McCanns they thought Maddie could be dead. He says yes.
3:47: Kate whispers something in Gerry’s ear and gives him a little smile. He stays looking straight in front.
3:52: Gerry has put his arm round Kate as they listen to Paiva’s testimony.
4:03: Paiva also says the McCanns were made suspects after the British sniffer dogs were brought in.
4:04: Paiva: there was total collaboration between British and Portuguese police on the case.
4:09: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
4:09: Paiva: Amaral’s theories are based on the facts of the investigation.
4:12: Paiva: Amaral’s thesis has prevented other theories from being investigated.
4:13: Paiva: McCanns never pointed me towards any evidence that Maddie was still alive.
4:16: Mr Amaral looks like he’s dozing off.
4:29: Paiva: we found the ‘merchandising’ operation with wristbands and so on very strange.
4:31: Paiva: if she was being held somewhere publicity would be more likely to hasten her death.
4:55: The McCanns’ lawyer is taking an aggressive tone as she cross-examines Mr Paiva.
5:08: Proceedings have ended for today.
5:11: Some confusion here – that wasn’t the end of proceedings, just a break before today’s final witness.
5:29: Ok, that’s all we have time for. Back tomorrow morning.

Leave a Reply

You can add images to your comment by clicking here.